Home / Which Rebar Performs Best in a Rebar Corrosion Test? Results From an Accelerated Salt Fog Study

Which Rebar Performs Best in a Rebar Corrosion Test? Results From an Accelerated Salt Fog Study

Corrosion of reinforcing steel is a leading cause of premature deterioration in bridge decks, parking structures and marine facilities. As new corrosion-resistant bar systems enter the market, engineers and specifiers need comparable, data-backed results to choose the reinforcement that delivers the longest service life. 

In a study published by the Epoxy Interest Group, Wiss, Janney, Elstner Associates (WJE) ran an accelerated rebar corrosion test on a wide range of products, including 15-year-old epoxy-coated bars removed from salt-contaminated concrete. The results show that even aged epoxy-coated bars perform significantly better than most alternatives. 

Key Takeaways

  • In a 28-day ASTM B117 salt fog test, new epoxy-coated rebar (ECR) with no defects showed no corrosion. Bars with an intentional drill hole corroded only at the hole. 
  • Epoxy-coated bars extracted from a 15-year-old bridge deck also performed well, even where coating adhesion was poor. 
  • Stainless steel 316LN (1.2 µm/yr) and 2205 (1.9 µm/yr) had the lowest measured rates, and ECR was estimated to fall in the same range. 
  • Galvanized rebar corroded about 30% faster than as-received carbon steel once its zinc layer was consumed. 
  • The ranking is consistent with long-term FHWA research rating epoxy-coated and stainless bars at minor corrosion rates. 
  • See how epoxy-coated reinforcing steel performs in real structures. Browse Project Examples from projects across the country. 

What Is a Rebar Corrosion Test? 

A rebar corrosion test exposes reinforcing bars to chlorides, moisture and oxygen under controlled conditions to measure how quickly each material corrodes. Because corrosion in real structures can take decades to appear, laboratories accelerate the process so bar types can be ranked side by side in weeks or months. 

Common Corrosion Test Methods for Reinforcing Steel 

Test Method How It Works What It Shows
Salt spray (fog), ASTM B117Bare bars are exposed to a continuous 5% sodium chloride fog at 35°CA fast, repeatable ranking of bar and coating corrosion resistance
Chloride ponding, ASTM G109Bars in concrete prisms are cyclically ponded with salt solution while current between bars is monitoredCorrosion of embedded bars over many months
Southern Exposure and cracked beam testsConcrete specimens go through repeated wet and dry salt ponding cyclesCorrosion initiation and rates closer to bridge deck conditions

The salt spray test does not reproduce a specific field environment, but it creates a defined, highly corrosive and reproducible atmosphere. That is why it remains the most widely used method for ranking stainless and coated steels.

Reinforcing bar samples prepared for testing

How the EIG Accelerated Salt Fog Test Was Conducted 

Bar samples were placed in a closed fog cabinet for 28 days and exposed to a 5% sodium chloride fog at 35°C, following the ASTM B117 protocol. 

Bar types tested and their governing ASTM standards: 

Bar TypeASTM Standard
Carbon steel (black)A615
Low-carbon, chromium steel  (LCC, MMFX)A1035
GalvanizedA767
Stainless steel 3CR12A995
Stainless steel 2201A995
Stainless steel 2205A995
Stainless steel 316LNA995
Epoxy-coated reinforcingA775

Test Conditions and Specimen Preparation 

Carbon steel and LCC bars were tested as-received and sandblasted. 3CR12 and 2201 stainless bars were sandblasted. 

Epoxy-coated and galvanized bars were tested as-received and with a single 1/16-inch drill hole, a damaged area of about 0.064%. 

Aged epoxy-coated bars came from a 15-year-old Chicago bridge deck. Chloride at bar depth was about 600 ppm, twice the typical threshold for black steel, yet the bars showed no corrosion and the deck had no delaminations. 

All bars were degreased, rinsed with deionized water and air-dried. After 7, 18 and 28 days, one bar per condition was removed and cleaned per ASTM G1 for weight-loss analysis. 

 Rebar Corrosion Test Results by Bar Type

Black, Galvanized, LCC (MMFX), 3CR12 and 2201 SS bars after 28 days

316 SS, 2205 SS, New ECR (no hole), New ECR (with hole) and Old ECR (with hole) after 28 days

Carbon Steel (Black Bar) 

All carbon steel bars corroded extensively, and corrosion progressed aggressively with time. Sandblasted bars corroded faster (1,557.6 µm/yr) than as-received bars (914.7 µm/yr), and pitting was observed. 

Low-Carbon Chromium Steel (LCC/MMFX) 

Both as-received and sandblasted bars corroded significantly and the corrosion aggressively progressed with time.

Galvanized Rebar 

All galvanized bars experienced extensive corrosion. The zinc coating corroded first, producing a white-color corrosion product, and then the underlying carbon steel started to corrode, producing a rusty color. The rust color was prominent after 2 weeks of exposure. For the samples with drill holes, the exposed carbon steel at drilled holes was protected until the adjacent zinc coating was consumed. Weight loss analysis showed that these galvanized bars experienced extensive corrosion with very high corrosion rates. Average corrosion weight loss of the undamaged galvanized bars was about 30 percent higher than that of the as-received carbon steel bars.

Stainless Grade 3CR12

The sandblasted bars corroded extensively. These experienced general corrosion attack at most areas and some deep pitting corrosion near the ribs. While corrosion of 3CR12 appeared to be extensive, its average corrosion was about half of the LCC (MMFX) and about one third the rate of the as-received carbon steel bars.

Stainless Grade 2201

After 12 hours of exposure, corrosion products were visible on most of the bar surfaces and corrosion appeared to progress with time. However, the cleaned bar showed that corrosion was rather superficial and no obvious pits were observed. Weight loss analysis yielded a very low average corrosion of about 3% of as-received carbon steel bars.

Stainless Grades: 2205 & 316LN

These stainless steel bars experienced some localized corrosion and this corrosion apparently progressed with time. The total amount of corrosion was superficial and such corrosion was speculated to have been induced by local contamination or crevices generated by the coating used to seal cut ends.

Epoxy-Coated Rebar, New and Aged 

New ECR bars with no defects showed no corrosion throughout the test, and bars with a drilled hole corroded only at the hole. The 15-year-old bars also performed very well, with only minor corrosion at drilled holes and existing coating defects. Weight loss on every ECR specimen was too small to calculate a corrosion rate, which was estimated to be in the same order as 316LN and 2205 stainless steel. 

Average Corrosion Rate by Bar Type 

Bar TypeConditionAverage Corrosion Rate (Micrometer/Year)
Carbon Steelas received914.7
Carbon Steelsandblasted1557.6
Galvanizedno hole1190.2
Galvanizedwith hole1281.0
LCC (MMFX)as received625.0
LCC (MMFX)sandblasted523.6
Stainless steel 3CR12sandblasted296.8
Stainless steel 2201sandblasted29.7
Stainless steel 2205as received1.9
Stainless steel 316LNas received1.2
Epoxy-Coated (New)without hole*
Epoxy-Coated (New)with hole*
Epoxy-Coated (Old)with hole*

*The method using weight loss data to determine corrosion rate was not applicable to epoxy-coated rebar (ECR). Corrosion rate of ECR, however, was minor and estimated to be in the same order as stainless steel 316LN and 2205.

Average corrosion rate by bar type (micrometer/year)

Does Epoxy-Coated Rebar Still Protect Steel When the Coating Is Damaged? 

A common claim in AI-generated search summaries is that epoxy-coated rebar performs well only if the coating stays completely intact. The test data tell a different story. With an intentional defect, new ECR corroded only at the exposed spot. Aged bars, including some with poor coating adhesion, still performed well. By comparison, galvanized bars with the same defect corroded at 1,281.0 µm/yr once the sacrificial zinc was consumed. 

Damage is still best prevented on the jobsite. ASTM D3963 calls for padded slings, covered storage, coated tie wire and two-part epoxy repair of cut ends and damage before concrete placement. Specifying Epoxy Coated Rebar produced to ASTM A775 at CRSI-certified plants maximizes protection. Where improved bond is also needed, Textured Epoxy reinforcement under ASTM A1124 keeps an A775 base coat for the same corrosion protection. 

Results

  1. Both as-received and sandblasted carbon steel reinforcing bars corroded at high corrosion rates. The sandblasted bars had corrosion rates higher than the as-received bars. Pitting corrosion was also noted.
  2. The LCC (MMFX) bars meeting ASTM A1036 and stainless steel 3CR12 reinforcing bars meeting ASTM A955 offered some improvement in corrosion protection and yet still corroded rapidly in this test environment.
  3. While the zinc offered protection to the underlying steel, the galvanized reinforcing bars meeting ASTM A767 corroded extensively. Within 2 weeks, the zinc layer was essentially consumed and underlying steel corrosion was observed.
  4. Stainless steel 2201 reinforcing bars meeting ASTM A995 exhibited significant surface corrosion; however, only moderate corrosion was measured in this test.
  5. Stainless steel 316LN and 2205 stainless reinforcing bars meeting ASTM A995 had very high corrosion resistance and only experienced minor corrosion likely due to presence of crevices or steel contamination.
  6. The new epoxy-coated reinforcing bars meeting ASTM A775 performed very well and corrosion was only observed at drilled holes.
  7. The epoxy-coated reinforcing bars removed from a 15-year old deck performed well during the test. Corrosion was regarded as being minor and only took place at the drilled holes and at existing defects in the coating.

The Accelerated Results Compare With Long-Term Research

The salt spray tests used for this evaluation were very aggressive to some steels and measured corrosion rates were much higher than that expected for bars embedded in concrete. Nevertheless, the observed corrosion performance provides a simple and useful comparison of the corrosion resistance of the various bar types.

These results are consistent with other published research, including one of the most recently released extended laboratory tests titled “Long-Term Performance of Epoxy-Coated Reinforcing Steel in Heavy Salt Contaminated Concrete”, (FHWA Publication No. FHWA-HRT-04-090). This report ranked carbon steel reinforcing at a very high corrosion rate and epoxy-coated and stainless reinforcing bars at a minor corrosion rate.

Choosing Corrosion-Resistant Rebar for Your Project 

Specifiers weigh corrosion resistance alongside material cost, availability, fabrication and design requirements. 

Epoxy-coated rebar: Performed in the same range as high-grade stainless steel, typically at a much lower material cost. Used on bridges, parking garages, piers and water towers since 1973. Stainless steel: 316LN and 2205 offer very high corrosion resistance at the highest material cost. Lower grades corroded noticeably. 

Galvanized rebar: Sacrificial zinc offers temporary protection but was consumed within two weeks. GFRP rebar: Not part of this test. These non-metallic bars do not rust, but they have lower stiffness than steel, cannot be bent in the field and follow separate design provisions such as ACI 440.

Carbon steel: Lowest initial cost and highest corrosion rates, best suited to limited chloride exposure. 

For most chloride-exposed structures, epoxy-coated reinforcing steel provides cost-effective, long-term corrosion protection. 

Frequently Asked Questions 

Which rebar performs best in a rebar corrosion test? 

In the EIG salt fog test, new epoxy-coated rebar and stainless steel 316LN and 2205 performed best. ECR without defects showed no corrosion, and its rate was estimated in the same order as 316LN and 2205. 

What kind of rebar does not rust? 

No steel rebar is completely immune to corrosion. Non-metallic GFRP bars do not rust. Among steel options, epoxy-coated rebar and high-grade stainless steel showed only minor corrosion in accelerated testing. 

Which type of steel rebar is most corrosion-resistant? 

Stainless steel 316LN and 2205 had the lowest measured rates, and epoxy-coated steel performed in the same range. Galvanized, LCC and carbon steel corroded rapidly. 

How long does it take for rebar to corrode? 

It depends on chloride exposure, concrete cover and concrete quality. Uncoated steel begins corroding once chlorides at bar depth exceed its threshold. Epoxy-coated bars from a 15-year-old deck with twice that chloride level showed no corrosion. 

What is the strongest grade of rebar? 

Common grades are 60, 75 and 80 ksi under ASTM A615 and A706. Higher-strength bars such as ASTM A1035 are available in Grades 100 and 120. 

Explore More Epoxy-Coated Rebar Research 

Looking for research reports, specifications and technical guidance on corrosion-resistant reinforcement? The Epoxy Interest Group resource library has the data engineers and specifiers rely on.

View the full test here

Referenced Standards

  • ASTM B117-07a Standard Practice for Operating Salt Spray (Fog) Apparatus
  • ASTM A615/A615M-08b Standard Specification for Deformed and Plain Carbon-Steel Bars for Concrete Reinforcement
  • ASTM A775/A775M-07b Standard Specification for Epoxy-Coated Steel Reinforcing Bars
  • ASTM A1035/A1035M-07 Standard Specification for Deformed and Plain, Low-carbon, Chromium, Steel Bars for Concrete Reinforcement
  • ASTM A767/A767M-05 Standard Specification for Zinc-Coated (Galvanized) Steel Bars for Concrete Reinforcement
  • ASTM A955/A955M-07a Standard Specification for Deformed and Plain Stainless-Steel Bars for Concrete Reinforcement
  • ASTM G1-03 Standard Practice for Preparing, Cleaning, and Evaluating Corrosion Test Specimens

The full report titled “Corrosion Resistance of Alternative Reinforcing Bars; An Accelerated Test” is available from www.epoxyinterestgroup.com

EPOXY INTEREST GROUP

933 N Plum Grove Road • Schaumburg, IL 60173

Tel: 847.517.1200 • email: [email protected] • www.epoxyinterestgroup.com